Skip to main content

THE FALLACY THAT IS PUBLIC EDUCATION: ARE YOU THAT EDUCATED?


One of the hardest things to embrace and accept in Kenya is that the public education system that a majority of us have gone through is a failure in its entirety and no matter how many patches we apply, or clutches we give it to stagger on, it still is a failure.


Typical Classroom in Kenya
Don’t get me wrong it worked fine in another century and a different generation, but its usefulness ended a long time ago and just because factories are producing typewriters it doesn't mean every person has to learn how to use one.

Let me clarify that statement, the problem with the public education system is that it is predicated on mechanical mass production where people go through a moving conveyor belt called the education system. They are grouped by age and expected to go through higher and higher levels of indoctrination so that at the end of the production line, they conform to a specific ‘quality’ assurance criteria that renders them ready to join other similarly standardized and sanitized group of people who will fulfill the economic agenda of the industrial market.
The industrial education system

The only problem with this approach is that while it was well suited for the industrial revolution of the 19th century. It is maladjusted for the 21st century and beyond.

The period between 18th and 19th century was unique in that it was the first time that millions of people living in abject poverty across the western world were able to leave servitude in the farmlands and productively take part in mechanized industries that progressively offered better wages.

This altered the social hierarchy and necessitated a transfer of wealth; a middle class arose that was more assertive and politically enfranchised and it demanded for more government involvement in state affairs. In time legislation was enacted in England and other industrialized countries to ensure schooling became compulsory.

With industrialization governments realized that more could be gained from a literate population. Subsequently, the education system was modeled around the prevailing economic requirements of the day. Studies show that part of the reason Prussia overtook England by the late 19th century in many sectors was due in part to its concerted effort in educating its population. 

Having said that it’s imperative to note that the education system was designed and conceived in the intellectual culture of the enlightenment, which lay emphasis on academic ability predicated on deductive reasoning and knowledge of the classics.

The genetic makeup of public education today is based on this logic, which then proceeds to group people into two: the academic and the non-academic, those who are smart and those who are not. Woe unto you if your lot is cast in the ‘not’ group. 
Because of this, more and more people have checked out of the system literally or mentally way before they graduate stifling their ability to learn.

It is unfortunate that with time this model of education has remained and become more entrenched. 

Today more than ever before the public school system destroys divergent thinking, which has come to be appreciated as essential for creativity. Apparently, high IQ does not guarantee creativity. 

"In 1968, George Land gave 1,600 5-year-olds a creativity test used by NASA to select innovative engineers and scientists. He then re-tested the same children at ages 10 and 15. The test results were staggering! 98% at age 5 registered genius level creativity, 30% at 10 year and 12% at 15 years of age. The same test given to 280,000 adults placed their genius level creativity at only 2% In his book 'Breakpoint and Beyond', co-authored by Beth Jarman, Land concluded that non-creative behavior is learned".

The conclusion is that there is something that happens to people during their formative schooling years that destroys their creativity. They lose more as they become educated.


Human beings are diverse and different. No amount of trying to make them similar will work. Most education systems around the world for the longest time have instilled conformity and dissuaded diversity.

Children on the other hand thrive in an education system that celebrates their broad range of talents, because it brings out elements of their psyche that are otherwise untouched.

We need to understand that teaching is a creative profession. It should stimulate, provoke and engage. Education should be about learning; there is no point in educating if there is no learning going on.  The task - teaching has to have an intended achievement - learning. The role of a teacher is to facilitate learning, not to dictate, indoctrinate or control a student.


In the recent past, education systems have focused not on teaching and learning but on testing. When students go to school in order to get a good grade and are propped up by exams, then all they do is memorize, they don’t learn or more importantly acquire skills essential to drive their countries’ economies into the 21st century.



Testing should be a diagnostic tool, not the reason for education; it should support learning and not inhibit it.

If you look at the Shanghai School System, which was noted as the best in the world by Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) latest report released in 2013, there are pertinent elements that could help any country transform it’s public education system:

  1. Individualize teaching and learning.   No learning can occur without relationships, understanding relationships is essential in learning. Great learning actually happens in groups, collaboration is the stuff of growth.
  2. Attribute a high status to the teaching profession. There is no education system in the world that is better than its teachers. Support them, value them and respect them. The Chinese have a long tradition in doing this.
  3. Chose great people who are passionate about the profession to be teachers. Support them in their professional development. Investing in professional development is not a cost but an investment. Teachers in Shanghai must complete 240 hours of professional development in five years.
  4. Devolve responsibility to the school level in getting the job done. Education and learning doesn't go on in the legislative rooms of government but rather in schools. If you remove this discretion learning stops working.
  5. Allow for broad and diverse curricula. China implemented in 2008, a renewed effort to encourage student learning rather than accumulation of knowledge, which led to eight curricular “learning domains” encompassing: Language and literature, Mathematics, Natural science, Social sciences, Technology, Arts, Physical education and Practicum
  6. Have close links with the community. This will allow for content that is geared towards the market. In Shanghai schools are encouraged to develop their own curriculum and outside groups such as museums became partners in education. Part of the new curriculum includes an emphasis on inquiry-based education.


Our rapidly advancing world depends on diversity and not singularity of skill and purpose.  Students’ questions are the seeds of real learning. They are the evidence of curiosity and the beginning of divergent thinking. Have you noticed how a 4-year-old child will ask so many questions, and as they grow older this ability recedes? Teachers have to embrace and nurture curiosity from both the students and themselves.

In education, change is highly dreaded, due to the possibility of failure. The messy process of trial and error needs to be celebrated and inculcated. Or else we will still be looking at the same education system 50 years from now, and still wonder what went wrong.

In the final analysis the real safety of a nation lies in preparing the next generation to take up its role, we can only do so if we get our act together in the education sector in Africa.

Mind you I have not mentioned the current situation, or spent time on the education problems that afflict Africa today. And they are many. What I would rather leave you with is a link that directs you to what China as a nation is doing to reform and develop its education system in order to empower its human resource by the year 2020.

Be inspired and lets change Africa.

Your comments are greatly appreciated so keep them coming.

Comments

  1. This is one of the best articles I have read on this subject. It pains me to see creativity murdered in classrooms and lecture halls. And I hate this other thing: How do you "teach" a child for 8 years and test them in 3 days, and the results seal their destiny? No wonder schools today are teaching how to pass exams instead of true laerning and creativity.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well said Mutinda. I propose a coming together of minds. Collaboration among equals and across professional boundaries to push for change.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Crush that Never Was, A Book Never Read

I was standing there with a rose. At least that's what Mr Patel told me it was. It was red and spiky. "Watch your hands and heart," he said. I was too flushed to say anything. The edges were wilting. I was sure I was a novice buyer for Mr Patel.     I walked into the restaurant and sat at the table closest to the door. I looked strange, a ten-year-old on a first date. My uncle had chided me for looking presentable, I wore a white shirt, trousers, socks and shoes. My nose assaulted by Brut, 'the essence of men'. So here I was nervous, and my heart pounding. This went on for a while before worry took over. "Had the girl forgotten to come? Was she held up in traffic?" Outside was a Saturday afternoon. The two streets in Nanyuki were deserted. I sighed, trying to calm down. My thoughts went back to when I had seen her. She was a new girl in our sister class, and the most beautiful person I had ever seen. Flawless dark skin, and teeth as white as dair

I Shall Live by Sight

My ears were sensitive to the noise and babel outside - loud music blaring, and cars honking. We were seated in a small room, deprived of light. There were other sounds, not as loud, of crawling creatures scurrying around. We were on the second floor of a building, that had sucked in air, to fit between other buildings that lacked a hint of design or flair in their construction. For a moment, I remembered the mason who did odd jobs at our house and wondered if he had constructed the buildings in this part of the city.   I looked outside the window, the lone window that allowed in reflected light. The lone window from which you could never see the sun, but still sense its presence. I wondered if a prisoner in solitary confinement desired the sun, the way I desired to leave that office.   Yet, we were there for a good reason. Seated beside me was my father, in a polo shirt and khaki slacks. He was relaxed and seemed oblivious of the surrounding. I looked across the tiny table. Th

The Key Heist

We all had those days, weeks, and months when something snapped, and we went a bit crazy. This is one such story I kept in the recess of my mind. I was barely ten years old.   "The phone is really nice and shiny," I said, reaching up. It was placed on a high cupboard, in a corner right outside my parent's room. It was kept there so we could also receive calls since our parents were always away working.   Unlike the one before, a quaint rotary system, this one was white and had buttons. It looked so light caged and padlocked in a metal contraption that held it down, hiding the buttons.   Big Sis was standing on a chair beside me engrossed. Her focus was on the manacles holding the phone buttons out of access. With no social media back then, and with little interest in television, Big Sis was looking at her only source of entertainment. The brightest girl in Laikipia District, based on her last award, was stumped. My eyes moved from her to the phone and wondered wha